S240910ci

Event ID: GW240910_103535 Trigger ID: S240910ci cbc-workflow-er16-o4b
Current version: 327b059a recorded 2026-07-28 13:42 UTC v3

History

Version history

Showing cached copy.
Viewing version e2805410 (historical) — not the current record

Selected version e2805410. Compared with previous version 1f7f8a7d.

Selected version details

Compare selected version
Loading version comparison…

Changes from previous version 1f7f8a7d to selected version e2805410

Change legend: Added exists only in the selected version; Removed exists only in the baseline; Changed has different values.

90 field changes.

  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › CatalogVersion
    Baseline
    3
    Selected
    4
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › FAR
    Baseline
    0.00000000000000000004003769
    Selected
    0.000000000000000000000000000000000000000003860165474024999
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › GPSTime
    Baseline
    1409999753.493817
    Selected
    1409999753.498092
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › H1SNR
    Baseline
    11.905187
    Selected
    11.855796
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › HasMassGap
    Baseline
    0.12696563735375618
    Selected
    0.15485828814948452
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › HasNS
    Baseline
    0.00009658645526228155
    Selected
    0.00011596393124153076
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › L1SNR
    Baseline
    13.047743
    Selected
    13.30229
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Mass1
    Baseline
    13.418396
    Selected
    13.219833
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Mass2
    Baseline
    6.783159
    Selected
    6.9165273
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › NetworkSNR
    Baseline
    17.662873
    Selected
    17.81883311932785
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Pastro
    Baseline
    1.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Pbbh
    Baseline
    1.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Pbns
    Baseline
    0.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Pipeline
    Baseline
    MBTA
    Selected
    gstlal
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Pnsbh
    Baseline
    0.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › SearchType
    Baseline
    low latency
    Selected
    offline
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Skymap
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 0 › SourceClassification
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/mbta.p_astro.json
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Spin1z
    Baseline
    0.149077
    Selected
    0.15468749
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › Spin2z
    Baseline
    0.149077
    Selected
    0.15468749
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › UID
    Baseline
    G510870
    Selected
    G602299
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 0 › XML
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/coinc.xml
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G602299/files/coinc.xml
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › CatalogVersion
    Baseline
    3
    Selected
    4
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › FAR
    Baseline
    0.000000000000273565194159914
    Selected
    0.0000000000656524
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › GPSTime
    Baseline
    1409999753.494629
    Selected
    1409999753.5039
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › H1SNR
    Baseline
    11.939525
    Selected
    139.6526
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › HasMassGap
    Baseline
    0.07906405674066999
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › HasNS
    Baseline
    0.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › HasRemnant
    Baseline
    0.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › L1SNR
    Baseline
    13.173222
    Selected
    101.3723
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › Mass1
    Baseline
    15.982637
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › Mass2
    Baseline
    5.9110823
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › NetworkSNR
    Baseline
    17.77880805599064
    Selected
    15.524976650546048
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 1 › Pastro
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.9997357188547424
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 1 › Pbbh
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.9997357188547424
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 1 › Pbns
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.0
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › Pipeline
    Baseline
    pycbc
    Selected
    CWB
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 1 › Pnsbh
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.0
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › SearchType
    Baseline
    offline
    Selected
    low latency
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › Skymap
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.multiorder.fits
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 1 › SourceClassification
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.p_astro.json
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › Spin1z
    Baseline
    0.25730249
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › Spin2z
    Baseline
    0.25730249
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 1 › UID
    Baseline
    G604176
    Selected
    G510874
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 1 › XML
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/coinc.xml
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › CatalogVersion
    Baseline
    3
    Selected
    4
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › FAR
    Baseline
    0.0000000000656524
    Selected
    0.000000000000273565194159914
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › GPSTime
    Baseline
    1409999753.5039
    Selected
    1409999753.494629
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › H1SNR
    Baseline
    139.6526
    Selected
    11.939525
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › HasMassGap
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.07906405674066999
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › HasNS
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.0
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › HasRemnant
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.0
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › L1SNR
    Baseline
    101.3723
    Selected
    13.173222
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › Mass1
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    15.982637
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › Mass2
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    5.9110823
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › NetworkSNR
    Baseline
    15.524976650546048
    Selected
    17.77880805599064
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 2 › Pastro
    Baseline
    0.9997357188547424
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 2 › Pbbh
    Baseline
    0.9997357188547424
    Selected
    Missing
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 2 › Pbns
    Baseline
    0.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › Pipeline
    Baseline
    CWB
    Selected
    pycbc
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 2 › Pnsbh
    Baseline
    0.0
    Selected
    Missing
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › SearchType
    Baseline
    low latency
    Selected
    offline
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › Skymap
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.multiorder.fits
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
  • Removed GraceDB › Events › 2 › SourceClassification
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.p_astro.json
    Selected
    Missing
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › Spin1z
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.25730249
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › Spin2z
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.25730249
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 2 › UID
    Baseline
    G510874
    Selected
    G604176
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 2 › XML
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/coinc.xml
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › CatalogVersion
    Baseline
    3
    Selected
    4
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › FAR
    Baseline
    0.000000000000000000000000000000000000000003860165474024999
    Selected
    0.000000000000000000007081053
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › GPSTime
    Baseline
    1409999753.498092
    Selected
    1409999753.49381
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › H1SNR
    Baseline
    11.855796
    Selected
    12.102069
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › HasMassGap
    Baseline
    0.15485828814948452
    Selected
    0.13641356024564885
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › HasNS
    Baseline
    0.00011596393124153076
    Selected
    0.00009548675380122253
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › L1SNR
    Baseline
    13.30229
    Selected
    13.064898
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › Mass1
    Baseline
    13.219833
    Selected
    13.418396
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › Mass2
    Baseline
    6.9165273
    Selected
    6.783159
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › NetworkSNR
    Baseline
    17.81883311932785
    Selected
    17.808752
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 3 › Pastro
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    1.0
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 3 › Pbbh
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.883333333
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 3 › Pbns
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.033333333
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › Pipeline
    Baseline
    gstlal
    Selected
    MBTA
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 3 › Pnsbh
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    0.083333333
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 3 › Skymap
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
  • Added GraceDB › Events › 3 › SourceClassification
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/mbta.p_astro.json
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › Spin1z
    Baseline
    0.15468749
    Selected
    0.149077
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › Spin2z
    Baseline
    0.15468749
    Selected
    0.149077
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › UID
    Baseline
    G602299
    Selected
    G612214
  • Changed GraceDB › Events › 3 › XML
    Baseline
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G602299/files/coinc.xml
    Selected
    https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/coinc.xml
  • Changed GraceDB › LastUpdate
    Baseline
    2025-09-26 12:45:47.933256
    Selected
    2025-10-25 12:35:21.442581
View raw JSON diff

Technical inspection aid only. The semantic summary above remains authoritative.

Baseline 1f7f8a7d

{"Info": {"Notes": [], "Labels": [], "SchemaVersion": "v3"}, "Sname": "S240910ci", "GraceDB": {"ADVOK": true, "Events": [{"FAR": 4.003769e-20, "UID": "G510870", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 1.0, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 11.905187, "HasNS": 9.658645526228155e-05, "L1SNR": 13.047743, "Mass1": 13.418396, "Mass2": 6.783159, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 1.0, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.149077, "Spin2z": 0.149077, "GPSTime": 1409999753.493817, "Pipeline": "MBTA", "HasMassGap": 0.12696563735375618, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.662873, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 3, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/mbta.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 2.73565194159914e-13, "UID": "G604176", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/coinc.xml", "H1SNR": 11.939525, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 13.173222, "Mass1": 15.982637, "Mass2": 5.9110823, "Notes": [], "State": "neighbor", "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.25730249, "Spin2z": 0.25730249, "GPSTime": 1409999753.494629, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.07906405674066999, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.77880805599064, "SearchType": "offline", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 3, "InOfflineCatalog": true}, {"FAR": 6.56524e-11, "UID": "G510874", "Pbbh": 0.9997357188547424, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 139.6526, "L1SNR": 101.3723, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9997357188547424, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1409999753.5039, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 15.524976650546048, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 3, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.860165474024999e-42, "UID": "G602299", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G602299/files/coinc.xml", "H1SNR": 11.855796, "HasNS": 0.00011596393124153076, "L1SNR": 13.30229, "Mass1": 13.219833, "Mass2": 6.9165273, "Notes": [], "State": "neighbor", "Spin1z": 0.15468749, "Spin2z": 0.15468749, "GPSTime": 1409999753.498092, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.15485828814948452, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.81883311932785, "SearchType": "offline", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 3, "InOfflineCatalog": true}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G510872", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.6909208731549286, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 12.004534, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 14.006596, "Mass1": 14.514339, "Mass2": 6.3547264, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.30753990231181055, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9984607754667392, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.41781057, "Spin2z": -0.50486759, "GPSTime": 1409999753.494629, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.09037329510735695, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 18.44704723271369, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "InOfflineCatalog": false, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2025-09-26 12:45:47.933256", "Instruments": "H1,L1", "SupereventFAR": 3.983024713156636e-29, "SupereventPastro": 1.0}, "Lensing": {"SingletAnalyses": {}, "MultipletAnalyses": {}}, "Cosmology": {"Notes": [], "Counterparts": [], "PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "CosmologyRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "CatalogTracking": {"Notes": [], "SearchResultStatuses": [{"UID": "MBTA", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}, {"UID": "pycbc", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}, {"UID": "CWB", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}, {"UID": "gstlal", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}], "ParameterEstimationStatuses": [{"UID": "IMRPhenomXPHM", "Notes": ["No production results satisfying request available, using best rota analysis instead"], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "CorrespondingPEUID": "Exp0", "IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult": false}, {"UID": "IllustrativeResult", "Notes": ["Adding illustrative result even though it does not fall into any requested categories"], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted", "CorrespondingPEUID": "online", "IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult": true}]}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": ["No posterior support for NSBH origin", "Preferred pipeline pycbc gave p_NSBH around 0.3, so it is HIGH_PROFILE", "Low-mass BBH with positive chi_eff"], "Status": "ongoing", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": ["Perform a review of the online result and assess if it is sufficent for sending a skymap.", "Results copied from /home/pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby", "Instructions can be found [here](https://git.ligo.org/pe/O4/o4b-rota/-/wikis/Review-instructions).", "Automatic online PE run succeeded", "When this file is updated add the contents as a comment on the relevant git issue.", "Low-mass BBH with moderately high SNR", "Online run was used to release updated skymap and issue GCN updates"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/G510872_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "13b5f68c5bd9bc1841ff70da33a3ac65", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 03:41:55"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/final_result/G510872_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "24a41d262526c9d886afb78256d98a62", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 04:48:46"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "ongoing", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "21b6b72197ac796cbb9908b5746207b4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 05:38:24"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomPv2"}, {"UID": "Exp0", "Notes": ["IMRXPHM run since online run was IMRPhenomPv2 given its mass", "Results very similar to online run, slight preference to higher q", "Some weak multimodality in online run absent in Exp0"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/G510872_EXP0_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "0d25a2a26ecf501f42e4c9bbcf7436b6", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 21:00:04"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/final_result/G510872_EXP0_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "70d7ec4e482fe81dda90258e7e8ccfd5", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 12:07:30"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "pass", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "7131eb1f454b1aa444598862d3c3cdd4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/15 20:13:44"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": ["hui.tong"], "Reviewers": ["aaron.zimmerman"], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "IllustrativeResult": "online", "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05, "SkymapReleaseResult": "online"}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [""], "Status": "complete", "Analysts": ["Kaylah McGowan", "kmcgowan@caltech.edu", "Derek Davis", "derek.davis@ligo.org", "Sophie Hourihane", "sophie.hourihane@ligo.org", "Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk", "Francesco Di Renzo", "f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr", "Siddharth Soni", "siddharth.soni@ligo.org"], "Reviewers": ["Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk"], "DQRResults": [{"UID": " ", "Notes": [""], "DQRFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "MD5Sum": "9b4fab8816f0e824cf46a4eb12fa7273", "PublicHTML": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "DateLastModified": "2025/01/23 14:47:56"}, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "ValidationNotes": [""], "ValidationResult": "pass"}], "RecommendedDuration": 32.0, "RecommendedDetectors": [{"UID": "H1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing."], "FrameType": "H1_HOFT_AR01", "RecommendedChannel": "H1:DCS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR01 ", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}, {"UID": "L1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing."], "FrameType": "L1_HOFT_AR01", "RecommendedChannel": "L1:DCS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR01", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}], "ParticipatingDetectors": ["H1", "L1"]}}

Selected e2805410

{"Info": {"Notes": [], "Labels": [], "SchemaVersion": "v3"}, "Sname": "S240910ci", "GraceDB": {"ADVOK": true, "Events": [{"FAR": 3.860165474024999e-42, "UID": "G602299", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G602299/files/coinc.xml", "H1SNR": 11.855796, "HasNS": 0.00011596393124153076, "L1SNR": 13.30229, "Mass1": 13.219833, "Mass2": 6.9165273, "Notes": [], "State": "neighbor", "Spin1z": 0.15468749, "Spin2z": 0.15468749, "GPSTime": 1409999753.498092, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.15485828814948452, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.81883311932785, "SearchType": "offline", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 4, "InOfflineCatalog": true}, {"FAR": 6.56524e-11, "UID": "G510874", "Pbbh": 0.9997357188547424, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 139.6526, "L1SNR": 101.3723, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9997357188547424, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1409999753.5039, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 15.524976650546048, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 4, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 2.73565194159914e-13, "UID": "G604176", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/coinc.xml", "H1SNR": 11.939525, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 13.173222, "Mass1": 15.982637, "Mass2": 5.9110823, "Notes": [], "State": "neighbor", "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.25730249, "Spin2z": 0.25730249, "GPSTime": 1409999753.494629, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.07906405674066999, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.77880805599064, "SearchType": "offline", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 4, "InOfflineCatalog": true}, {"FAR": 7.081053e-21, "UID": "G612214", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.883333333, "Pbns": 0.033333333, "H1SNR": 12.102069, "HasNS": 9.548675380122253e-05, "L1SNR": 13.064898, "Mass1": 13.418396, "Mass2": 6.783159, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.083333333, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 1.0, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.149077, "Spin2z": 0.149077, "GPSTime": 1409999753.49381, "Pipeline": "MBTA", "HasMassGap": 0.13641356024564885, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.808752, "SearchType": "offline", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 4, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/mbta.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G510872", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.6909208731549286, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 12.004534, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 14.006596, "Mass1": 14.514339, "Mass2": 6.3547264, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.30753990231181055, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9984607754667392, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.41781057, "Spin2z": -0.50486759, "GPSTime": 1409999753.494629, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.09037329510735695, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 18.44704723271369, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "InOfflineCatalog": false, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2025-10-25 12:35:21.442581", "Instruments": "H1,L1", "SupereventFAR": 3.983024713156636e-29, "SupereventPastro": 1.0}, "Lensing": {"SingletAnalyses": {}, "MultipletAnalyses": {}}, "Cosmology": {"Notes": [], "Counterparts": [], "PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "CosmologyRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "CatalogTracking": {"Notes": [], "SearchResultStatuses": [{"UID": "MBTA", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}, {"UID": "pycbc", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}, {"UID": "CWB", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}, {"UID": "gstlal", "Chunk": 0, "Notes": [], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted"}], "ParameterEstimationStatuses": [{"UID": "IMRPhenomXPHM", "Notes": ["No production results satisfying request available, using best rota analysis instead"], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "CorrespondingPEUID": "Exp0", "IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult": false}, {"UID": "IllustrativeResult", "Notes": ["Adding illustrative result even though it does not fall into any requested categories"], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted", "CorrespondingPEUID": "online", "IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult": true}]}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": ["No posterior support for NSBH origin", "Preferred pipeline pycbc gave p_NSBH around 0.3, so it is HIGH_PROFILE", "Low-mass BBH with positive chi_eff"], "Status": "ongoing", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": ["Perform a review of the online result and assess if it is sufficent for sending a skymap.", "Results copied from /home/pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby", "Instructions can be found [here](https://git.ligo.org/pe/O4/o4b-rota/-/wikis/Review-instructions).", "Automatic online PE run succeeded", "When this file is updated add the contents as a comment on the relevant git issue.", "Low-mass BBH with moderately high SNR", "Online run was used to release updated skymap and issue GCN updates"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/G510872_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "13b5f68c5bd9bc1841ff70da33a3ac65", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 03:41:55"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/final_result/G510872_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "24a41d262526c9d886afb78256d98a62", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 04:48:46"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "ongoing", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "21b6b72197ac796cbb9908b5746207b4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 05:38:24"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomPv2"}, {"UID": "Exp0", "Notes": ["IMRXPHM run since online run was IMRPhenomPv2 given its mass", "Results very similar to online run, slight preference to higher q", "Some weak multimodality in online run absent in Exp0"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/G510872_EXP0_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "0d25a2a26ecf501f42e4c9bbcf7436b6", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 21:00:04"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/final_result/G510872_EXP0_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "70d7ec4e482fe81dda90258e7e8ccfd5", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 12:07:30"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "pass", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "7131eb1f454b1aa444598862d3c3cdd4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/15 20:13:44"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": ["hui.tong"], "Reviewers": ["aaron.zimmerman"], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "IllustrativeResult": "online", "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05, "SkymapReleaseResult": "online"}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [""], "Status": "complete", "Analysts": ["Kaylah McGowan", "kmcgowan@caltech.edu", "Derek Davis", "derek.davis@ligo.org", "Sophie Hourihane", "sophie.hourihane@ligo.org", "Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk", "Francesco Di Renzo", "f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr", "Siddharth Soni", "siddharth.soni@ligo.org"], "Reviewers": ["Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk"], "DQRResults": [{"UID": " ", "Notes": [""], "DQRFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "MD5Sum": "9b4fab8816f0e824cf46a4eb12fa7273", "PublicHTML": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "DateLastModified": "2025/01/23 14:47:56"}, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "ValidationNotes": [""], "ValidationResult": "pass"}], "RecommendedDuration": 32.0, "RecommendedDetectors": [{"UID": "H1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing."], "FrameType": "H1_HOFT_AR01", "RecommendedChannel": "H1:DCS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR01 ", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}, {"UID": "L1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing."], "FrameType": "L1_HOFT_AR01", "RecommendedChannel": "L1:DCS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR01", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}], "ParticipatingDetectors": ["H1", "L1"]}}

Metadata for selected version

Viewing historical metadata — not the current record

Summary

No summary highlights available.

Info

All remaining fields

Notes
Empty list
Labels
Empty list
SchemaVersion
v3

GraceDB

All remaining fields

ADVOK
✓ True
Events
Item 1
FAR
3.860165474024999e-42
UID
G602299
XML
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G602299/files/coinc.xml
H1SNR
11.855796
HasNS
0.00011596393124153076
L1SNR
13.30229
Mass1
13.219833
Mass2
6.9165273
Notes
Empty list
State
neighbor
Spin1z
0.15468749
Spin2z
0.15468749
GPSTime
1409999753.498092
Pipeline
gstlal
HasMassGap
0.15485828814948452
HasRemnant
0.0
NetworkSNR
17.81883311932785
SearchType
offline
EarlyWarning
✗ False
CatalogNumber
5
CatalogVersion
4
InOfflineCatalog
✓ True
Item 2
FAR
6.56524e-11
UID
G510874
Pbbh
0.9997357188547424
Pbns
0.0
H1SNR
139.6526
L1SNR
101.3723
Notes
Empty list
Pnsbh
0.0
State
neighbor
Pastro
0.9997357188547424
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.multiorder.fits
GPSTime
1409999753.5039
Pipeline
CWB
NetworkSNR
15.524976650546048
SearchType
low latency
EarlyWarning
✗ False
CatalogNumber
5
CatalogVersion
4
InOfflineCatalog
✓ True
SourceClassification
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.p_astro.json
Item 3
FAR
2.73565194159914e-13
UID
G604176
XML
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/coinc.xml
H1SNR
11.939525
HasNS
0.0
L1SNR
13.173222
Mass1
15.982637
Mass2
5.9110823
Notes
Empty list
State
neighbor
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G604176/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
Spin1z
0.25730249
Spin2z
0.25730249
GPSTime
1409999753.494629
Pipeline
pycbc
HasMassGap
0.07906405674066999
HasRemnant
0.0
NetworkSNR
17.77880805599064
SearchType
offline
EarlyWarning
✗ False
CatalogNumber
5
CatalogVersion
4
InOfflineCatalog
✓ True
Item 4
FAR
7.081053e-21
UID
G612214
XML
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/coinc.xml
Pbbh
0.883333333
Pbns
0.033333333
H1SNR
12.102069
HasNS
9.548675380122253e-05
L1SNR
13.064898
Mass1
13.418396
Mass2
6.783159
Notes
Empty list
Pnsbh
0.083333333
State
neighbor
Pastro
1.0
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
Spin1z
0.149077
Spin2z
0.149077
GPSTime
1409999753.49381
Pipeline
MBTA
HasMassGap
0.13641356024564885
HasRemnant
0.0
NetworkSNR
17.808752
SearchType
offline
EarlyWarning
✗ False
CatalogNumber
5
CatalogVersion
4
InOfflineCatalog
✓ True
SourceClassification
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G612214/files/mbta.p_astro.json
Item 5
FAR
3.167545842243851e-10
UID
G510872
XML
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/coinc.xml
Pbbh
0.6909208731549286
Pbns
0.0
H1SNR
12.004534
HasNS
0.0
L1SNR
14.006596
Mass1
14.514339
Mass2
6.3547264
Notes
Empty list
Pnsbh
0.30753990231181055
State
preferred
Pastro
0.9984607754667392
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
Spin1z
0.41781057
Spin2z
-0.50486759
GPSTime
1409999753.494629
Pipeline
pycbc
HasMassGap
0.09037329510735695
HasRemnant
0.0
NetworkSNR
18.44704723271369
SearchType
low latency
EarlyWarning
✗ False
InOfflineCatalog
✗ False
SourceClassification
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/pycbc.p_astro.json
LastUpdate
2025-10-25 12:35:21.442581
Instruments
H1,L1
SupereventFAR
3.983024713156636e-29
SupereventPastro
1.0

Parameter estimation (PE)

All remaining fields

Notes
Item 1
No posterior support for NSBH origin
Item 2
Preferred pipeline pycbc gave p_NSBH around 0.3, so it is HIGH_PROFILE
Item 3
Low-mass BBH with positive chi_eff
Status
ongoing
Results
Item 1
UID
online
Notes
Item 1
Perform a review of the online result and assess if it is sufficent for sending a skymap.
Item 2
Results copied from /home/pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby
Item 3
Instructions can be found [here](https://git.ligo.org/pe/O4/o4b-rota/-/wikis/Review-instructions).
Item 4
Automatic online PE run succeeded
Item 5
When this file is updated add the contents as a comment on the relevant git issue.
Item 6
Low-mass BBH with moderately high SNR
Item 7
Online run was used to release updated skymap and issue GCN updates
RunStatus
complete
ConfigFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/G510872_config_complete.ini
MD5Sum
13b5f68c5bd9bc1841ff70da33a3ac65
DateLastModified
2024/09/10 03:41:55
Deprecated
✗ False
ResultFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/final_result/G510872_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5
MD5Sum
24a41d262526c9d886afb78256d98a62
DateLastModified
2024/09/10 04:48:46
Publications
Empty list
ReviewStatus
ongoing
PESummaryPageURL
https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/home.html
InferenceSoftware
bilby
PESummaryResultFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5
MD5Sum
21b6b72197ac796cbb9908b5746207b4
DateLastModified
2024/09/10 05:38:24
WaveformApproximant
IMRPhenomPv2
Item 2
UID
Exp0
Notes
Item 1
IMRXPHM run since online run was IMRPhenomPv2 given its mass
Item 2
Results very similar to online run, slight preference to higher q
Item 3
Some weak multimodality in online run absent in Exp0
RunStatus
complete
ConfigFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/G510872_EXP0_config_complete.ini
MD5Sum
0d25a2a26ecf501f42e4c9bbcf7436b6
DateLastModified
2024/09/11 21:00:04
Deprecated
✗ False
ResultFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/final_result/G510872_EXP0_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5
MD5Sum
70d7ec4e482fe81dda90258e7e8ccfd5
DateLastModified
2024/09/11 12:07:30
Publications
Empty list
ReviewStatus
pass
PESummaryPageURL
https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/home.html
InferenceSoftware
bilby
PESummaryResultFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5
MD5Sum
7131eb1f454b1aa444598862d3c3cdd4
DateLastModified
2024/09/15 20:13:44
WaveformApproximant
IMRPhenomXPHM
Analysts
Item 1
hui.tong
Reviewers
Item 1
aaron.zimmerman
SafeSamplingRate
4096.0
IllustrativeResult
online
SafeLowerMassRatio
0.05
SkymapReleaseResult
online

Lensing

Detector characterisation (Detchar)

All remaining fields

Notes
Item 1
""
Status
complete
Analysts
Item 1
Kaylah McGowan
Item 2
kmcgowan@caltech.edu
Item 3
Derek Davis
Item 4
derek.davis@ligo.org
Item 5
Sophie Hourihane
Item 6
sophie.hourihane@ligo.org
Item 7
Laura Nuttall
Item 8
laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk
Item 9
Francesco Di Renzo
Item 10
f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr
Item 11
Siddharth Soni
Item 12
siddharth.soni@ligo.org
Reviewers
Item 1
Laura Nuttall
Item 2
laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk
DQRResults
Item 1
UID
Notes
Item 1
""
DQRFile
Path
CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html
MD5Sum
9b4fab8816f0e824cf46a4eb12fa7273
PublicHTML
https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html
DateLastModified
2025/01/23 14:47:56
ReviewStatus
pass
ValidationNotes
Item 1
""
ValidationResult
pass
RecommendedDuration
32.0
RecommendedDetectors
Item 1
UID
H1
Notes
Item 1
No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing.
FrameType
H1_HOFT_AR01
RecommendedChannel
H1:DCS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR01
GlitchMitigationStatus
not required
RecommendedMinimumFrequency
20
Item 2
UID
L1
Notes
Item 1
No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing.
FrameType
L1_HOFT_AR01
RecommendedChannel
L1:DCS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR01
GlitchMitigationStatus
not required
RecommendedMinimumFrequency
20
ParticipatingDetectors
Item 1
H1
Item 2
L1

Extreme matter

Cosmology

All remaining fields

Notes
Empty list
Counterparts
Empty list
PreferredLowLatencySkymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
CosmologyRunsUsingThisSuperevent
Empty list

Catalogue tracking

All remaining fields

Notes
Empty list
SearchResultStatuses
Item 1
UID
MBTA
Chunk
0
Notes
Empty list
Finalized
✗ False
ReviewStatus
unstarted
Item 2
UID
pycbc
Chunk
0
Notes
Empty list
Finalized
✗ False
ReviewStatus
unstarted
Item 3
UID
CWB
Chunk
0
Notes
Empty list
Finalized
✗ False
ReviewStatus
unstarted
Item 4
UID
gstlal
Chunk
0
Notes
Empty list
Finalized
✗ False
ReviewStatus
unstarted
ParameterEstimationStatuses
Item 1
UID
IMRPhenomXPHM
Notes
Item 1
No production results satisfying request available, using best rota analysis instead
Finalized
✗ False
ReviewStatus
pass
CorrespondingPEUID
Exp0
IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult
✗ False
Item 2
UID
IllustrativeResult
Notes
Item 1
Adding illustrative result even though it does not fall into any requested categories
Finalized
✗ False
ReviewStatus
unstarted
CorrespondingPEUID
online
IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult
✓ True

Publications

Additional metadata: Sname

All remaining fields

Sname
S240910ci

Additional metadata: TestingGR

Additional metadata: RatesAndPopulations