S240910ci

Event ID: GW240910_103535 Trigger ID: S240910ci cbc-workflow-er16-o4b
Current version: 327b059a recorded 2026-07-28 13:42 UTC v3

History

Version history

Viewing version b39e25bc (historical) — not the current record

Selected version b39e25bc. Compared with previous version 5a99a047.

Selected version details

Compare selected version
Loading version comparison…

Changes from previous version 5a99a047 to selected version b39e25bc

Change legend: Added exists only in the selected version; Removed exists only in the baseline; Changed has different values.

2 field changes.

  • Added CatalogTracking › ParameterEstimationStatuses › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    {'UID': 'IMRPhenomXPHM', 'Notes': ['No production results satisfying request available, using best rota analysis instead'], 'Finalized': False, 'ReviewStatus': 'pass', 'CorrespondingPEUID': 'Exp0', 'IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult': False}
  • Added CatalogTracking › ParameterEstimationStatuses › 1
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    {'UID': 'IllustrativeResult', 'Notes': ['Adding illustrative result even though it does not fall into any requested categories'], 'Finalized': False, 'ReviewStatus': 'unstarted', 'CorrespondingPEUID': 'online', 'IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult': True}
View raw JSON diff

Technical inspection aid only. The semantic summary above remains authoritative.

Baseline 5a99a047

{"Info": {"Notes": [], "Labels": [], "SchemaVersion": "v3"}, "Sname": "S240910ci", "GraceDB": {"ADVOK": true, "Events": [{"FAR": 4.003769e-20, "UID": "G510870", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 1.0, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 11.905187, "HasNS": 9.658645526228155e-05, "L1SNR": 13.047743, "Mass1": 13.418396, "Mass2": 6.783159, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 1.0, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.149077, "Spin2z": 0.149077, "GPSTime": 1409999753.493817, "Pipeline": "MBTA", "HasMassGap": 0.12696563735375618, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.662873, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/mbta.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G510872", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.6909208731549286, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 12.004534, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 14.006596, "Mass1": 14.514339, "Mass2": 6.3547264, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.30753990231181055, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9984607754667392, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.41781057, "Spin2z": -0.50486759, "GPSTime": 1409999753.494629, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.09037329510735695, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 18.44704723271369, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 6.56524e-11, "UID": "G510874", "Pbbh": 0.9997357188547424, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 139.6526, "L1SNR": 101.3723, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9997357188547424, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1409999753.5039, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 15.524976650546048, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.983024713156636e-29, "UID": "G510878", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510878/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9992437088089213, "Pbns": 2.3026411336671244e-48, "H1SNR": 12.080787, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 13.71304, "Mass1": 14.946656, "Mass2": 6.2140763, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0007562911910785774, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9999999999999999, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510878/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.20109375, "Spin2z": 0.20109375, "GPSTime": 1409999753.493774, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.11406453677325785, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 18.27547217185014, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510878/files/gstlal.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2025-04-18 11:57:03.187475", "Instruments": "H1,L1", "SupereventFAR": 3.983024713156636e-29, "SupereventPastro": 1.0}, "Lensing": {"SingletAnalyses": {}, "MultipletAnalyses": {}}, "Cosmology": {"Notes": [], "Counterparts": [], "PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "CosmologyRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "CatalogTracking": {"Notes": [], "SearchResultStatuses": [], "ParameterEstimationStatuses": []}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": ["No posterior support for NSBH origin", "Preferred pipeline pycbc gave p_NSBH around 0.3, so it is HIGH_PROFILE", "Low-mass BBH with positive chi_eff"], "Status": "complete", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": ["Perform a review of the online result and assess if it is sufficent for sending a skymap.", "Results copied from /home/pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby", "Instructions can be found [here](https://git.ligo.org/pe/O4/o4b-rota/-/wikis/Review-instructions).", "Automatic online PE run succeeded", "When this file is updated add the contents as a comment on the relevant git issue.", "Low-mass BBH with moderately high SNR", "Online run was used to release updated skymap and issue GCN updates"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/G510872_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "13b5f68c5bd9bc1841ff70da33a3ac65", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 03:41:55"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/final_result/G510872_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "24a41d262526c9d886afb78256d98a62", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 04:48:46"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "pass", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "21b6b72197ac796cbb9908b5746207b4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 05:38:24"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomPv2"}, {"UID": "Exp0", "Notes": ["IMRXPHM run since online run was IMRPhenomPv2 given its mass", "Results very similar to online run, slight preference to higher q", "Some weak multimodality in online run absent in Exp0"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/G510872_EXP0_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "0d25a2a26ecf501f42e4c9bbcf7436b6", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 21:00:04"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/final_result/G510872_EXP0_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "70d7ec4e482fe81dda90258e7e8ccfd5", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 12:07:30"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "pass", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "7131eb1f454b1aa444598862d3c3cdd4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/15 20:13:44"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": ["hui.tong"], "Reviewers": ["aaron.zimmerman"], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "IllustrativeResult": "online", "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05, "SkymapReleaseResult": "online"}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [""], "Status": "complete", "Analysts": ["Kaylah McGowan", "kmcgowan@caltech.edu", "Derek Davis", "derek.davis@ligo.org", "Sophie Hourihane", "sophie.hourihane@ligo.org", "Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk", "Francesco Di Renzo", "f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr", "Siddharth Soni", "siddharth.soni@ligo.org"], "Reviewers": ["Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk"], "DQRResults": [{"UID": " ", "Notes": [""], "DQRFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "MD5Sum": "9b4fab8816f0e824cf46a4eb12fa7273", "PublicHTML": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "DateLastModified": "2025/01/23 14:47:56"}, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "ValidationNotes": [""], "ValidationResult": "pass"}], "RecommendedDuration": 32.0, "RecommendedDetectors": [{"UID": "H1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing. "], "FrameType": "H1_HOFT_C00_AR", "RecommendedChannel": "H1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}, {"UID": "L1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing. "], "FrameType": "L1_HOFT_C00_AR", "RecommendedChannel": "L1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}], "ParticipatingDetectors": ["H1", "L1"]}}

Selected b39e25bc

{"Info": {"Notes": [], "Labels": [], "SchemaVersion": "v3"}, "Sname": "S240910ci", "GraceDB": {"ADVOK": true, "Events": [{"FAR": 4.003769e-20, "UID": "G510870", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 1.0, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 11.905187, "HasNS": 9.658645526228155e-05, "L1SNR": 13.047743, "Mass1": 13.418396, "Mass2": 6.783159, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 1.0, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.149077, "Spin2z": 0.149077, "GPSTime": 1409999753.493817, "Pipeline": "MBTA", "HasMassGap": 0.12696563735375618, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 17.662873, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510870/files/mbta.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G510872", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.6909208731549286, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 12.004534, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 14.006596, "Mass1": 14.514339, "Mass2": 6.3547264, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.30753990231181055, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9984607754667392, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.41781057, "Spin2z": -0.50486759, "GPSTime": 1409999753.494629, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.09037329510735695, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 18.44704723271369, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 6.56524e-11, "UID": "G510874", "Pbbh": 0.9997357188547424, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 139.6526, "L1SNR": 101.3723, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9997357188547424, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1409999753.5039, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 15.524976650546048, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510874/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.983024713156636e-29, "UID": "G510878", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510878/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9992437088089213, "Pbns": 2.3026411336671244e-48, "H1SNR": 12.080787, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 13.71304, "Mass1": 14.946656, "Mass2": 6.2140763, "Notes": [], "Pnsbh": 0.0007562911910785774, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9999999999999999, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510878/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.20109375, "Spin2z": 0.20109375, "GPSTime": 1409999753.493774, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.11406453677325785, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 18.27547217185014, "SearchType": "low latency", "EarlyWarning": false, "CatalogNumber": "5", "CatalogVersion": 1, "InOfflineCatalog": true, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510878/files/gstlal.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2025-04-18 11:57:03.187475", "Instruments": "H1,L1", "SupereventFAR": 3.983024713156636e-29, "SupereventPastro": 1.0}, "Lensing": {"SingletAnalyses": {}, "MultipletAnalyses": {}}, "Cosmology": {"Notes": [], "Counterparts": [], "PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G510872/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "CosmologyRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "CatalogTracking": {"Notes": [], "SearchResultStatuses": [], "ParameterEstimationStatuses": [{"UID": "IMRPhenomXPHM", "Notes": ["No production results satisfying request available, using best rota analysis instead"], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "CorrespondingPEUID": "Exp0", "IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult": false}, {"UID": "IllustrativeResult", "Notes": ["Adding illustrative result even though it does not fall into any requested categories"], "Finalized": false, "ReviewStatus": "unstarted", "CorrespondingPEUID": "online", "IsDesignatedIllustrativeResult": true}]}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": ["No posterior support for NSBH origin", "Preferred pipeline pycbc gave p_NSBH around 0.3, so it is HIGH_PROFILE", "Low-mass BBH with positive chi_eff"], "Status": "complete", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": ["Perform a review of the online result and assess if it is sufficent for sending a skymap.", "Results copied from /home/pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby", "Instructions can be found [here](https://git.ligo.org/pe/O4/o4b-rota/-/wikis/Review-instructions).", "Automatic online PE run succeeded", "When this file is updated add the contents as a comment on the relevant git issue.", "Low-mass BBH with moderately high SNR", "Online run was used to release updated skymap and issue GCN updates"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/G510872_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "13b5f68c5bd9bc1841ff70da33a3ac65", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 03:41:55"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/bilby/final_result/G510872_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "24a41d262526c9d886afb78256d98a62", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 04:48:46"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "pass", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/online/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "21b6b72197ac796cbb9908b5746207b4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/10 05:38:24"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomPv2"}, {"UID": "Exp0", "Notes": ["IMRXPHM run since online run was IMRPhenomPv2 given its mass", "Results very similar to online run, slight preference to higher q", "Some weak multimodality in online run absent in Exp0"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/G510872_EXP0_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "0d25a2a26ecf501f42e4c9bbcf7436b6", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 21:00:04"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/bilby/final_result/G510872_EXP0_data0_1409999753-4990234_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "70d7ec4e482fe81dda90258e7e8ccfd5", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/11 12:07:30"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "pass", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "PESummaryResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4b/S240910ci/Exp0/summary/samples/posterior_samples.h5", "MD5Sum": "7131eb1f454b1aa444598862d3c3cdd4", "DateLastModified": "2024/09/15 20:13:44"}, "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": ["hui.tong"], "Reviewers": ["aaron.zimmerman"], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "IllustrativeResult": "online", "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05, "SkymapReleaseResult": "online"}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [""], "Status": "complete", "Analysts": ["Kaylah McGowan", "kmcgowan@caltech.edu", "Derek Davis", "derek.davis@ligo.org", "Sophie Hourihane", "sophie.hourihane@ligo.org", "Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk", "Francesco Di Renzo", "f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr", "Siddharth Soni", "siddharth.soni@ligo.org"], "Reviewers": ["Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk"], "DQRResults": [{"UID": " ", "Notes": [""], "DQRFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "MD5Sum": "9b4fab8816f0e824cf46a4eb12fa7273", "PublicHTML": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202409/S240910ci/index.html", "DateLastModified": "2025/01/23 14:47:56"}, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "ValidationNotes": [""], "ValidationResult": "pass"}], "RecommendedDuration": 32.0, "RecommendedDetectors": [{"UID": "H1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing. "], "FrameType": "H1_HOFT_C00_AR", "RecommendedChannel": "H1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}, {"UID": "L1", "Notes": ["No DQ issues in H1 or L1; both omegascans look clean, both in the middle of long locks. No glitches were identified. V1 not observing. "], "FrameType": "L1_HOFT_C00_AR", "RecommendedChannel": "L1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN_AR", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}], "ParticipatingDetectors": ["H1", "L1"]}}