S231123cg

Event ID: GW231123_135430 Trigger ID: S231123cg cbc-workflow-o4a
Current version: 43d85b89 recorded 2026-07-28 13:35 UTC v3

History

Version history

Showing cached copy.
Viewing version db2eca70 (historical) — not the current record

Selected version db2eca70. Compared with previous version a78aada1.

Selected version details

Compare selected version
Loading version comparison…

Changes from previous version a78aada1 to selected version db2eca70

Change legend: Added exists only in the selected version; Removed exists only in the baseline; Changed has different values.

14 field changes.

  • Changed GraceDB › LastUpdate
    Baseline
    2023-11-27 08:00:27.561460
    Selected
    2023-11-27 09:02:51.313333
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Analysts › 2
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    nihar.gupte
  • Changed ParameterEstimation › Results › 3 › Deprecated
    Baseline
    True
    Selected
    False
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 3 › Notes › 4
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Rerun of Exp1 but with NRSur7dq4
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 3 › Notes › 5
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Results are sane but very different from XPHM runs
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 3 › PESummaryPageURL
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp2/summary/home.html
  • Changed ParameterEstimation › Results › 3 › ReviewStatus
    Baseline
    fail
    Selected
    pass
  • Changed ParameterEstimation › Results › 4 › Deprecated
    Baseline
    False
    Selected
    True
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 4 › Notes › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Bimodality in mass and spin
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 4 › Notes › 1
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Rerun of Exp1 but without XPHM ROQ and with time marginalization
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 4 › Notes › 2
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Posteriors for one chain recover tilt1 to be exactly antialigned
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 4 › Notes › 3
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Posteriors for one chain rail strongly against minimum mass ratio
  • Added ParameterEstimation › Results › 4 › PESummaryPageURL
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp3/summary/home.html
  • Changed ParameterEstimation › Results › 4 › ReviewStatus
    Baseline
    unstarted
    Selected
    fail
View raw JSON diff

Technical inspection aid only. The semantic summary above remains authoritative.

Baseline a78aada1

{"Info": {"Notes": []}, "Sname": "S231123cg", "GraceDB": {"Events": [{"FAR": 6.48194e-11, "UID": "G454710", "Pbbh": 0.9993509958810466, "Pbns": 0.0, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9993509958810466, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454710/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1384782888.6406, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 21.451454496140816, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454710/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G454708", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9999923972950012, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 13.231977, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 15.301665, "Mass1": 243.65358, "Mass2": 23.25828, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9999923972950012, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.55006188, "Spin2z": 0.55006188, "GPSTime": 1384782888.634277, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 20.22933917548619, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 0.0001861265754106921, "UID": "G454706", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454706/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.003449885957051149, "Pbns": 6.047718284061438e-91, "H1SNR": 13.119816, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 15.348683, "Mass1": 183.9621, "Mass2": 191.81351, "Pnsbh": 6.99008468271413e-89, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.003449885957051202, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454706/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.88171875, "Spin2z": 0.88171875, "GPSTime": 1384782888.6535, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 20.1918708424914, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454706/files/gstlal.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2023-11-27 08:00:27.561460", "Instruments": "H1,L1"}, "Lensing": {"Analyses": []}, "Cosmology": {"PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits"}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": [], "Status": "ongoing", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": ["Automatic online PE run succeeded", "Results copied from /home/pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/online/bilby", "Posteriors show trimodality and data includes a glitch below 30Hz in Hanford"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/online/bilby/G454708_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "f7b6f6747643e6ea46eee7ad93b33007", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 06:00:52"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/online/bilby/final_result/G454708_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "ea8367afbeb86fc4f3ebbd62682ea908", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 15:34:19"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}, {"UID": "Exp0", "Notes": ["Results show bimodality", "Rerun of the online PE but with flow=30Hz in Hanford", "One of the chains misses the extreme mass ratio mode", "Sky location posteriors different from online and Exp1"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp0/bilby/Exp0_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "9be78ad2e02a1cc0103620c86a8157bd", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 07:02:41"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp0/bilby/final_result/Exp0_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "2d87f4ef4e0b40dcc7b06f6f7e1e08b5", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 09:57:18"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp0/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}, {"UID": "Exp1", "Notes": ["tilt1 is recovered to be exactly antialigned", "Rerun of the online PE but with flow=30Hz in Hanford and nlive=1000", "ROQ sanity check narrowly fails", "Sky location posteriors are different from Exp0 and online", "Results show bimodality"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp1/bilby/Exp1_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "0130a56a24ecccf20f5c3ab4feeb3893", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/24 00:59:23"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp1/bilby/final_result/Exp1_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "70e1483801654a44b0344d07fa30b4e7", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/24 12:18:13"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp1/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}, {"UID": "Exp2", "Notes": ["Bimodality in mass and spin", "Posteriors for one chain recover tilt1 to be exactly antialigned", "Rerun of Exp1 but without XPHM ROQ and with time marginalization", "Posteriors for one chain rail strongly against minimum mass ratio"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp2/bilby/Exp2_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "6f5fe3154e390de91e07ef201e9c76cf", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/25 06:42:18"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp2/bilby/final_result/Exp2_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "c999cd8196092d1451aa111e89fd6fdd", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/27 00:33:21"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "NRSur7dq4"}, {"UID": "Exp3", "Notes": [], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp3/bilby/Exp3_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "55089eefc3e1a2e6780e7cfcca894768", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/25 14:12:44"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp3/bilby/final_result/Exp3_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "a0f05c778130a40c2164253ec5ee6c60", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/26 23:13:50"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "unstarted", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": ["miquel.miravet", "sylvia.biscoveanu"], "Reviewers": ["Soichiro Morisaki", "Sylvia Biscoveanu", "soichiro.morisaki", "sylvia.biscoveanu"], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [], "Status": "unstarted", "Analysts": [], "Reviewers": [], "DQRResults": [], "RecommendedDetectors": [], "ParticipatingDetectors": []}}

Selected db2eca70

{"Info": {"Notes": []}, "Sname": "S231123cg", "GraceDB": {"Events": [{"FAR": 6.48194e-11, "UID": "G454710", "Pbbh": 0.9993509958810466, "Pbns": 0.0, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9993509958810466, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454710/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1384782888.6406, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 21.451454496140816, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454710/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G454708", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9999923972950012, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 13.231977, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 15.301665, "Mass1": 243.65358, "Mass2": 23.25828, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9999923972950012, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.55006188, "Spin2z": 0.55006188, "GPSTime": 1384782888.634277, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 20.22933917548619, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 0.0001861265754106921, "UID": "G454706", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454706/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.003449885957051149, "Pbns": 6.047718284061438e-91, "H1SNR": 13.119816, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 15.348683, "Mass1": 183.9621, "Mass2": 191.81351, "Pnsbh": 6.99008468271413e-89, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.003449885957051202, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454706/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.88171875, "Spin2z": 0.88171875, "GPSTime": 1384782888.6535, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 20.1918708424914, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454706/files/gstlal.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2023-11-27 09:02:51.313333", "Instruments": "H1,L1"}, "Lensing": {"Analyses": []}, "Cosmology": {"PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G454708/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits"}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": [], "Status": "ongoing", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": ["Automatic online PE run succeeded", "Results copied from /home/pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/online/bilby", "Posteriors show trimodality and data includes a glitch below 30Hz in Hanford"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/online/bilby/G454708_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "f7b6f6747643e6ea46eee7ad93b33007", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 06:00:52"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/online/bilby/final_result/G454708_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "ea8367afbeb86fc4f3ebbd62682ea908", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 15:34:19"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}, {"UID": "Exp0", "Notes": ["Results show bimodality", "Rerun of the online PE but with flow=30Hz in Hanford", "One of the chains misses the extreme mass ratio mode", "Sky location posteriors different from online and Exp1"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp0/bilby/Exp0_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "9be78ad2e02a1cc0103620c86a8157bd", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 07:02:41"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp0/bilby/final_result/Exp0_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "2d87f4ef4e0b40dcc7b06f6f7e1e08b5", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/23 09:57:18"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp0/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}, {"UID": "Exp1", "Notes": ["tilt1 is recovered to be exactly antialigned", "Rerun of the online PE but with flow=30Hz in Hanford and nlive=1000", "ROQ sanity check narrowly fails", "Sky location posteriors are different from Exp0 and online", "Results show bimodality"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp1/bilby/Exp1_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "0130a56a24ecccf20f5c3ab4feeb3893", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/24 00:59:23"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp1/bilby/final_result/Exp1_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "70e1483801654a44b0344d07fa30b4e7", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/24 12:18:13"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp1/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}, {"UID": "Exp2", "Notes": ["Bimodality in mass and spin", "Posteriors for one chain recover tilt1 to be exactly antialigned", "Rerun of Exp1 but without XPHM ROQ and with time marginalization", "Posteriors for one chain rail strongly against minimum mass ratio", "Rerun of Exp1 but with NRSur7dq4", "Results are sane but very different from XPHM runs"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp2/bilby/Exp2_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "6f5fe3154e390de91e07ef201e9c76cf", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/25 06:42:18"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp2/bilby/final_result/Exp2_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "c999cd8196092d1451aa111e89fd6fdd", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/27 00:33:21"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "pass", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp2/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "NRSur7dq4"}, {"UID": "Exp3", "Notes": ["Bimodality in mass and spin", "Rerun of Exp1 but without XPHM ROQ and with time marginalization", "Posteriors for one chain recover tilt1 to be exactly antialigned", "Posteriors for one chain rail strongly against minimum mass ratio"], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp3/bilby/Exp3_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "55089eefc3e1a2e6780e7cfcca894768", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/25 14:12:44"}, "Deprecated": true, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231123cg/Exp3/bilby/final_result/Exp3_data0_1384782888-6342773_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "a0f05c778130a40c2164253ec5ee6c60", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/26 23:13:50"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "fail", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231123cg/Exp3/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": ["miquel.miravet", "sylvia.biscoveanu", "nihar.gupte"], "Reviewers": ["Soichiro Morisaki", "Sylvia Biscoveanu", "soichiro.morisaki", "sylvia.biscoveanu"], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [], "Status": "unstarted", "Analysts": [], "Reviewers": [], "DQRResults": [], "RecommendedDetectors": [], "ParticipatingDetectors": []}}