S231118d

Event ID: GW231118_005626 Trigger ID: S231118d cbc-workflow-o4a
Current version: 43d85b89 recorded 2026-07-28 13:35 UTC v3

History

Version history

Showing cached copy.
Viewing version fdc3f87c (historical) — not the current record

Selected version fdc3f87c. Compared with previous version b1f5aa24.

Selected version details

Compare selected version
Loading version comparison…

Changes from previous version b1f5aa24 to selected version fdc3f87c

Change legend: Added exists only in the selected version; Removed exists only in the baseline; Changed has different values.

22 field changes.

  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Debasmita Nandi
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 1
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    debasmita.nandi@ligo.org
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 2
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Derek Davis
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 3
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    derek.davis@ligo.org
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 4
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Sophie Hourihane
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 5
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    sophie.hourihane@ligo.org
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 6
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Laura Nuttall
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 7
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 8
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Francesco Di Renzo
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 9
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 10
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Siddharth Soni
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Analysts › 11
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    siddharth.soni@ligo.org
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › DQRResults › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    {'UID': ' ', 'Notes': [''], 'DQRFile': {'Path': 'CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202311/S231118d/index.html', 'MD5Sum': 'd7a7111ede260d82f2ffdee88c6fdf45', 'PublicHTML': 'https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202311/S231118d/index.html', 'DateLastModified': '2023/11/17 22:13:12'}, 'ReviewStatus': 'pass', 'ValidationNotes': [''], 'ValidationResult': 'pass'}
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Notes › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › ParticipatingDetectors › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    H1
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › ParticipatingDetectors › 1
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    L1
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › RecommendedDetectors › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    {'UID': 'H1', 'Notes': ['Please also run with default PE settings, Noise present in Hanford below 30 Hz'], 'FrameType': 'H1_HOFT_C00', 'RecommendedChannel': 'H1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN', 'GlitchMitigationStatus': 'required', 'RecommendedMinimumFrequency': 30}
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › RecommendedDetectors › 1
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    {'UID': 'L1', 'Notes': ['Please also run with default PE settings, Noise present in Hanford below 30 Hz'], 'FrameType': 'L1_HOFT_C00', 'RecommendedChannel': 'L1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN', 'GlitchMitigationStatus': 'not required', 'RecommendedMinimumFrequency': 20}
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › RecommendedDuration
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    16.0
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Reviewers › 0
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    Laura Nuttall
  • Added DetectorCharacterization › Reviewers › 1
    Baseline
    Missing
    Selected
    laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk
  • Changed DetectorCharacterization › Status
    Baseline
    unstarted
    Selected
    ongoing
View raw JSON diff

Technical inspection aid only. The semantic summary above remains authoritative.

Baseline b1f5aa24

{"Info": {"Notes": []}, "Sname": "S231118d", "GraceDB": {"Events": [{"FAR": 1.27154e-05, "UID": "G453548", "Pbbh": 0.0010315860106941965, "Pbns": 0.0, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.0010315860106941965, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453548/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1384304204.8438, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 9.56563118670169, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453548/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G453547", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9998122327777423, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 7.4695735, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 7.7988229, "Mass1": 24.695326, "Mass2": 16.880877, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9998122327777423, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.3871178, "Spin2z": 0.3871178, "GPSTime": 1384304204.844727, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 10.7988965431185, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 1.334354365603285e-12, "UID": "G453546", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9999974375854827, "Pbns": 5.907877821349465e-24, "H1SNR": 7.4912868, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 7.2074609, "Mass1": 25.801163, "Mass2": 15.625333, "Pnsbh": 3.8194641779859026e-22, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9999974375854827, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.34031251, "Spin2z": 0.34031251, "GPSTime": 1384304204.845319, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.0007407407407407407, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 10.39552161175799, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/gstlal.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.232378276152303e-08, "UID": "G453544", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9636030755197135, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 7.0198364, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 7.233222, "Mass1": 26.777121, "Mass2": 15.843009, "Pnsbh": 0.0012757883078408669, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9648788638275544, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.8910448, "Spin2z": -0.51837289, "GPSTime": 1384304204.847656, "Pipeline": "spiir", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 10.07956368391735, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/spiir.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2023-11-27 04:02:10.699791", "Instruments": "H1,L1"}, "Lensing": {"Analyses": []}, "Cosmology": {"PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits"}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": [], "Status": "complete", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": [], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231118d/online/bilby/G453547_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "3bbc2ded8d3cc229f525562f2f74caf3", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/17 17:02:35"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231118d/online/bilby/final_result/G453547_data0_1384304204-8447266_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "9113a3fc39e2d340cf33caa0bbff76b2", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/18 04:43:48"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "unstarted", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231118d/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": [], "Reviewers": [], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [], "Status": "unstarted", "Analysts": [], "Reviewers": [], "DQRResults": [], "RecommendedDetectors": [], "ParticipatingDetectors": []}}

Selected fdc3f87c

{"Info": {"Notes": []}, "Sname": "S231118d", "GraceDB": {"Events": [{"FAR": 1.27154e-05, "UID": "G453548", "Pbbh": 0.0010315860106941965, "Pbns": 0.0, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.0010315860106941965, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453548/files/cwb.multiorder.fits", "GPSTime": 1384304204.8438, "Pipeline": "CWB", "NetworkSNR": 9.56563118670169, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453548/files/cwb.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.167545842243851e-10, "UID": "G453547", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9998122327777423, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 7.4695735, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 7.7988229, "Mass1": 24.695326, "Mass2": 16.880877, "Pnsbh": 0.0, "State": "preferred", "Pastro": 0.9998122327777423, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.3871178, "Spin2z": 0.3871178, "GPSTime": 1384304204.844727, "Pipeline": "pycbc", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 10.7988965431185, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/pycbc.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 1.334354365603285e-12, "UID": "G453546", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9999974375854827, "Pbns": 5.907877821349465e-24, "H1SNR": 7.4912868, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 7.2074609, "Mass1": 25.801163, "Mass2": 15.625333, "Pnsbh": 3.8194641779859026e-22, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9999974375854827, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.34031251, "Spin2z": 0.34031251, "GPSTime": 1384304204.845319, "Pipeline": "gstlal", "HasMassGap": 0.0007407407407407407, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 10.39552161175799, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/gstlal.p_astro.json"}, {"FAR": 3.232378276152303e-08, "UID": "G453544", "XML": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/coinc.xml", "Pbbh": 0.9636030755197135, "Pbns": 0.0, "H1SNR": 7.0198364, "HasNS": 0.0, "L1SNR": 7.233222, "Mass1": 26.777121, "Mass2": 15.843009, "Pnsbh": 0.0012757883078408669, "State": "neighbor", "Pastro": 0.9648788638275544, "Skymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits", "Spin1z": 0.8910448, "Spin2z": -0.51837289, "GPSTime": 1384304204.847656, "Pipeline": "spiir", "HasMassGap": 0.0, "HasRemnant": 0.0, "NetworkSNR": 10.07956368391735, "SourceClassification": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/spiir.p_astro.json"}], "LastUpdate": "2023-11-27 04:02:10.699791", "Instruments": "H1,L1"}, "Lensing": {"Analyses": []}, "Cosmology": {"PreferredLowLatencySkymap": "https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits"}, "TestingGR": {"Notes": [], "BHMAnalyses": [], "FTIAnalyses": [], "MDRAnalyses": [], "POLAnalyses": [], "SIMAnalyses": [], "SMAAnalyses": [], "SSBAnalyses": [], "LOSAAnalyses": [], "IMRCTAnalyses": [], "TIGERAnalyses": [], "PCATGRAnalyses": [], "PYRINGAnalyses": [], "PSEOBRDAnalyses": [], "EchoesCWBAnalyses": [], "ResidualsAnalyses": [], "ModeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "UnmodeledEchoesAnalyses": [], "QNMRationalFilterAnalyses": []}, "Publications": {"Papers": []}, "ExtremeMatter": {"Analyses": []}, "ParameterEstimation": {"Notes": [], "Status": "complete", "Results": [{"UID": "online", "Notes": [], "RunStatus": "complete", "ConfigFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231118d/online/bilby/G453547_config_complete.ini", "MD5Sum": "3bbc2ded8d3cc229f525562f2f74caf3", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/17 17:02:35"}, "Deprecated": false, "ResultFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231118d/online/bilby/final_result/G453547_data0_1384304204-8447266_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5", "MD5Sum": "9113a3fc39e2d340cf33caa0bbff76b2", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/18 04:43:48"}, "Publications": [], "ReviewStatus": "unstarted", "PESummaryPageURL": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231118d/online/summary/home.html", "InferenceSoftware": "bilby", "WaveformApproximant": "IMRPhenomXPHM"}], "Analysts": [], "Reviewers": [], "SafeSamplingRate": 4096.0, "SafeLowerMassRatio": 0.05}, "RatesAndPopulations": {"RnPRunsUsingThisSuperevent": []}, "DetectorCharacterization": {"Notes": [""], "Status": "ongoing", "Analysts": ["Debasmita Nandi", "debasmita.nandi@ligo.org", "Derek Davis", "derek.davis@ligo.org", "Sophie Hourihane", "sophie.hourihane@ligo.org", "Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk", "Francesco Di Renzo", "f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr", "Siddharth Soni", "siddharth.soni@ligo.org"], "Reviewers": ["Laura Nuttall", "laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk"], "DQRResults": [{"UID": " ", "Notes": [""], "DQRFile": {"Path": "CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202311/S231118d/index.html", "MD5Sum": "d7a7111ede260d82f2ffdee88c6fdf45", "PublicHTML": "https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202311/S231118d/index.html", "DateLastModified": "2023/11/17 22:13:12"}, "ReviewStatus": "pass", "ValidationNotes": [""], "ValidationResult": "pass"}], "RecommendedDuration": 16.0, "RecommendedDetectors": [{"UID": "H1", "Notes": ["Please also run with default PE settings, Noise present in Hanford below 30 Hz"], "FrameType": "H1_HOFT_C00", "RecommendedChannel": "H1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 30}, {"UID": "L1", "Notes": ["Please also run with default PE settings, Noise present in Hanford below 30 Hz"], "FrameType": "L1_HOFT_C00", "RecommendedChannel": "L1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN", "GlitchMitigationStatus": "not required", "RecommendedMinimumFrequency": 20}], "ParticipatingDetectors": ["H1", "L1"]}}

Metadata for selected version

Viewing historical metadata — not the current record

Summary

No summary highlights available.

Info

GraceDB

All remaining fields

Events
Item 1
FAR
1.27154e-05
UID
G453548
Pbbh
0.0010315860106941965
Pbns
0.0
Pnsbh
0.0
State
neighbor
Pastro
0.0010315860106941965
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453548/files/cwb.multiorder.fits
GPSTime
1384304204.8438
Pipeline
CWB
NetworkSNR
9.56563118670169
SourceClassification
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453548/files/cwb.p_astro.json
Item 2
FAR
3.167545842243851e-10
UID
G453547
XML
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/coinc.xml
Pbbh
0.9998122327777423
Pbns
0.0
H1SNR
7.4695735
HasNS
0.0
L1SNR
7.7988229
Mass1
24.695326
Mass2
16.880877
Pnsbh
0.0
State
preferred
Pastro
0.9998122327777423
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
Spin1z
0.3871178
Spin2z
0.3871178
GPSTime
1384304204.844727
Pipeline
pycbc
HasMassGap
0.0
HasRemnant
0.0
NetworkSNR
10.7988965431185
SourceClassification
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/pycbc.p_astro.json
Item 3
FAR
1.334354365603285e-12
UID
G453546
XML
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/coinc.xml
Pbbh
0.9999974375854827
Pbns
5.907877821349465e-24
H1SNR
7.4912868
HasNS
0.0
L1SNR
7.2074609
Mass1
25.801163
Mass2
15.625333
Pnsbh
3.8194641779859026e-22
State
neighbor
Pastro
0.9999974375854827
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
Spin1z
0.34031251
Spin2z
0.34031251
GPSTime
1384304204.845319
Pipeline
gstlal
HasMassGap
0.0007407407407407407
HasRemnant
0.0
NetworkSNR
10.39552161175799
SourceClassification
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453546/files/gstlal.p_astro.json
Item 4
FAR
3.232378276152303e-08
UID
G453544
XML
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/coinc.xml
Pbbh
0.9636030755197135
Pbns
0.0
H1SNR
7.0198364
HasNS
0.0
L1SNR
7.233222
Mass1
26.777121
Mass2
15.843009
Pnsbh
0.0012757883078408669
State
neighbor
Pastro
0.9648788638275544
Skymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits
Spin1z
0.8910448
Spin2z
-0.51837289
GPSTime
1384304204.847656
Pipeline
spiir
HasMassGap
0.0
HasRemnant
0.0
NetworkSNR
10.07956368391735
SourceClassification
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453544/files/spiir.p_astro.json
LastUpdate
2023-11-27 04:02:10.699791
Instruments
H1,L1

Parameter estimation (PE)

All remaining fields

Notes
Empty list
Status
complete
Results
Item 1
UID
online
Notes
Empty list
RunStatus
complete
ConfigFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231118d/online/bilby/G453547_config_complete.ini
MD5Sum
3bbc2ded8d3cc229f525562f2f74caf3
DateLastModified
2023/11/17 17:02:35
Deprecated
✗ False
ResultFile
Path
CIT:/home/pe.o4/public_html/O4a/S231118d/online/bilby/final_result/G453547_data0_1384304204-8447266_analysis_H1L1_merge_result.hdf5
MD5Sum
9113a3fc39e2d340cf33caa0bbff76b2
DateLastModified
2023/11/18 04:43:48
Publications
Empty list
ReviewStatus
unstarted
PESummaryPageURL
https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o4/O4a/S231118d/online/summary/home.html
InferenceSoftware
bilby
WaveformApproximant
IMRPhenomXPHM
Analysts
Empty list
Reviewers
Empty list
SafeSamplingRate
4096.0
SafeLowerMassRatio
0.05

Lensing

Detector characterisation (Detchar)

All remaining fields

Notes
Item 1
""
Status
ongoing
Analysts
Item 1
Debasmita Nandi
Item 2
debasmita.nandi@ligo.org
Item 3
Derek Davis
Item 4
derek.davis@ligo.org
Item 5
Sophie Hourihane
Item 6
sophie.hourihane@ligo.org
Item 7
Laura Nuttall
Item 8
laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk
Item 9
Francesco Di Renzo
Item 10
f.di-renzo@ip2i.in2p3.fr
Item 11
Siddharth Soni
Item 12
siddharth.soni@ligo.org
Reviewers
Item 1
Laura Nuttall
Item 2
laura.nuttall@port.ac.uk
DQRResults
Item 1
UID
Notes
Item 1
""
DQRFile
Path
CIT:/home/dqr/public_html/o4dqr/online/events/202311/S231118d/index.html
MD5Sum
d7a7111ede260d82f2ffdee88c6fdf45
PublicHTML
https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~dqr/o4dqr/online/events/202311/S231118d/index.html
DateLastModified
2023/11/17 22:13:12
ReviewStatus
pass
ValidationNotes
Item 1
""
ValidationResult
pass
RecommendedDuration
16.0
RecommendedDetectors
Item 1
UID
H1
Notes
Item 1
Please also run with default PE settings, Noise present in Hanford below 30 Hz
FrameType
H1_HOFT_C00
RecommendedChannel
H1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN
GlitchMitigationStatus
required
RecommendedMinimumFrequency
30
Item 2
UID
L1
Notes
Item 1
Please also run with default PE settings, Noise present in Hanford below 30 Hz
FrameType
L1_HOFT_C00
RecommendedChannel
L1:GDS-CALIB_STRAIN_CLEAN
GlitchMitigationStatus
not required
RecommendedMinimumFrequency
20
ParticipatingDetectors
Item 1
H1
Item 2
L1

Extreme matter

Cosmology

All remaining fields

PreferredLowLatencySkymap
https://gracedb.ligo.org/api/events/G453547/files/bayestar.multiorder.fits

Publications

Additional metadata: Sname

All remaining fields

Sname
S231118d

Additional metadata: TestingGR

Additional metadata: RatesAndPopulations